Month: March 2025

  • Wishlist from Union Budget 2025

    Wishlist from Union Budget 2025

    Table of Contents

    The budget 2025 is around the corner amidst a looming global tariff war of all sorts. The rupee is depreciating like never before and the stock market is quite overvalued with foreign institutional investors not showing much interest in India. The GDP growth is predicted to be around a modest 6%. Modest because as per most experts, India needs to grow at 12% for 8-10 years to get anywhere near vision of viksit Bharat. The general sense is that the big players are getting bigger and MSMEs and salaried class are struggling to cope up with the rising inflation and compounding effect of over-taxation. Its no secret that for India to grow at 12% more MSME need to transition to large corporations. Surely this budget can do its bit. Easy access to real estate for startup factories: There is no shortage of engineering graduates with the ambition to set up factories and create employment. A major stumbling block for setting up a factory is the availability of factory land and building with all permissions . The Government must focus on providing plug and play Factory infrastructure with all approvals in place. To make it cost effective the rent payable for such infrastructure by startup factories should be offset against the GST generated by such factories from their output atleast for 2 Years. Allow low interest Collateral free loans for First Machinery : Another major hindrance is Banking sector’s obsession with collateral. Govt must allow banks to give a loan of upto Rs 50 lakhs for purchase of machinery without any collateral and without previous “3 Year financial statement” requirement. Take urgent measures to Control inflation in food, education and medical- these areas hurt a worker in factory the maximum. This results in high cost for the factories and makes ultimate cost of production uncompetitive. The goal should be to help young brilliant people in opening factories. Instead of Ease of Doing business, government should focus on ease of starting business.
  • Realise the potential of your Accountant

    Realise the potential of your Accountant

    Table of Contents

    Over the years my interaction with business owners and founders has revealed a startling fact about how they perceive the accounts department.  For most business owners, accounting is administrative costs to handle tax and year-end book closures. The humble accountant is mostly perceived as a data entry operator who has to enter all bills, make cheques, keep the books in balance, file GST returns and interact with the CA. What they are forgetting is that the accountant if given proper training can be the first line of defence against inefficiencies in a company or even against fraud. For this the founders and business owners should allow the accountant to ask questions from other departments eg. the purchase department, the stores  and operations. Such interactions can help the accountant to understand the bills coming to accounts department and even question them in case something looks not regular. All this adds up in creating a control environment in the company and makes the accountant also a part of the organisation rather than a data entry operator!

  • ESOP guide for Startups

    ESOP guide for Startups

    Table of Contents

    ESOP can mean “Employee Stock OwnershipPlan” or “Employee Stock Option Plan”. Although in the Indian context it is generally used in the option sense. 

    Louis Orth Kelso was an American lawyer and economist accredited with the invention of employee stock ownership plans. Such was the impact of his invention that he was considered by many to be ahead of his time. 

    The first employee stock ownership plan was put into effect by Kelso in 1956 to enable the employees of Peninsula Newspapers Inc. in Palo Alto, Calif., to buy the newspaper chain. 

    In 1958 Kelso along with his co-author Mortimer J. Adler, explained the macro-economic theory behind employee stock options in his book “The Capitalist Manifesto”. Kelso and Mortimer pointed out that democracy cannot flourish under all economic conditions. Men cannot exercise freedom in the political sphere when they are deprived of economic freedom. Economic freedom can be achieved only if a person is not a slave. A person who has no property beyond his labour-power is also a slave. A slave works for the profit of other men and has no economic independence i.e he is dependent for subsistence on the will of another man and does not have freedom from toil or freedom for leisure. Even after the introduction of democracy, most people would fall under the meaning of slaves since the stock ownership is compressed in the hands of very few. A worker is economically dependent on the company he works for and does not enjoy freedom for leisure. Kelso advocated the use of Employee Stock Ownership plans (ESOP) to democratize access to capital, diffuse ownership of corporates, and save people from Economic Slavery in the corporate world.

    Years later ESOP continues to be relevant in corporate world but more so in the startup industry.

    How and when the word “ownership” was replaced in some industries by “options” is a mystery. In Employee ownership plan the employees are granted shares upfront and no option is attached. In Employee option plan there is a “call” option available to employees at end of a vesting period. This replacement of option with ownership is quiet intelligent since it captures the very essence of a carrot and stick approach. The Carrot being grant of company stock and the stick is for employees to give their best in employment for a period of time to the company and other qualifying conditions -( discussed later).

    Over the years I have explained the concept to many founders and still keep getting the same questions. So this blog will help any company owner of startup founder to know the basics of this ESOP phenomenon as a starting point for successful implementation of the ESOP programme. To keep things simple and fast I have given below a series of questions and answers based on my experience in this area.

    Q: What is an Employee Stock ownership plan?

    A: An Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) is a program that allows employees to become owners of shares in their employing company.

    Here’s a basic rundown:

    1. Company Contribution: Instead of the      employee purchasing stock, the company contributes shares of its own stock      or money to buy shares to the ESOP trust for the benefit of the employees.
    2. Vesting: Employees gradually earn the right      to the shares allocated to them over a period, known as the vesting      period. This could range from immediate vesting to several years.
    3. Ownership: Employees receive their shares      upon leaving the company, often in the form of company stock or as cash      after the company buys back the shares.

    Q: What is an employee stock option plan?

    An Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP) is a program that gives employees the option to purchase company stock at a set price after a certain period of time. It’s a way for companies to reward and incentivize their employees by offering them a stake in the company’s success.

    The main benefits of ESOPs include:

    • Aligning Interests: Employees become      shareholders, aligning their interests with those of the company and other      shareholders.
    • Incentivizing Performance: Employees are      motivated to work harder and contribute to the company’s growth, as they      stand to gain financially if the company’s stock price increases.
    • Retention Tool: ESOPs can help companies      retain talented employees by providing them with a long-term financial      incentive.

    Q: How do I know whether ESO(ownership)P or ESO(option)P is good for my company? Should I really be going for this?

    A:  This can be explained with any example : Lets say your company is a contract manufacturer -with no specialised technology. Chances are that for such company it will be difficult to find any investors at all. Without a foreseeable market for the shares of the company the employee stock options will have not much value for employees even if they are granted. However if the profit margin in the business is good, the Employee Ownership plan may be a very good idea to enable all or some employee participate in the profit of the Company. However if your company business is in an area which generates a lot interest in Investors and market eg. Is in AI or Crypto or blockchain or fintech or some futuristic technology. In such companies the profit may also not be there in the initial phase since its new area with lot of spend on R&D and brand building/marketing . Such company can make good use of ESO(Option) Plans. From the angle of the company the replacement of cash compensation with stock compensation would mean more cash available for research , development and marketing. Employees would also look forward to have some compensation in the form of options because they know that there is a medium to high probability of converting stock option into something of value and the upside can be huge. 

    Q: What happens if the employee decides to leave the company?

    Q: What the typical events in an Employee Stock Option plan?

    1. Grant: The company grants employees the      option to buy a specific number of shares at a predetermined price, known      as the exercise or strike price.
    2. Vesting Period: Employees must typically      wait for a certain period, known as the vesting period, before they can      exercise their options. This period could range from months to several      years.
    3. Exercise: Once the options are vested,      employees can exercise them, meaning they can buy the company’s stock at      the strike price, regardless of the current market price

    Q: What is are the general conditions to attached during the vesting period for grant of options ?

    Q: What is the tax impact on Employees

    Q: What is the tax impact of ESOP on the company?

  • Are loans good for business & how to get first loan for startups

    Are loans good for business & how to get first loan for startups

    Table of Contents

    The first part of this blog deals with fairly simple looking question i.e . “Are loans good for business”? This question at first looks simple as most would say Yes. Simply because loan involves a fixed payment which works as a leverage for an entrepreneur to generate alpha over the fixed payments. But this is always fraught with risk as business failure and startup losses are quiet commonplace. So careful analysis of the project and business by an independent CA or financial advisor is a must before even filing your loan application. I would highly recommend any person going for a loan to consult a professional with skill at analysing business from financial viability perspective. Sign a non disclosure agreement with the consultant and then prepare to answer all the questions so that he or she can give you an objective feedback on your business plan. This is a very critical step. No matter how much experienced or educated you are , an evaluation by an independent expert with fresh eyes is always beneficial.

    So once you have done that and got a green light you can consider the options which I have narrated below for loans.

    Getting your first business loan is always difficult especially at a lower interest rate. If you are a startup founder or an entrepreneur who has recently started business and need to take advantage of loans then this blog will surely help you. For ease of reference, I have written this blog based on the specific time you are seeking loans:

    Phase 1: 0-24 months into the business: This is the most difficult phase of your business. Many businesses fail in this phase even before taking off.